Perched on my kitchen stool, I hunched ever so slightly over the latest issue of Bon Appetit. I could not help but salivate over a recipe that would soon be brimming on my stovetop. But as my eyes glanced down the ingredient list, I winced with disappointment while the mental debate ensued as to whether the dish could be made kosher. I mean, really, what can you substitute for clam juice? And of course the real underlying question: after all of the necessary substitutions are made, would it even be worth it after distorting the intended taste with so many replacement ingredients? Jewish cooks of yesteryear did not have such conflicts of interest. Many of the products we so commonly use today, like margarine or soymilk, either did not exist or were not readily available. But more than that, Jewish cooks were comfortable with their cuisine and cooking traditions, no matter what their nationality. Their food might have been Persian or Italian, but what defined their food as “Jewish” was that it was cooked in a kosher way – it was guided more by mitzvot than ethnicity. Modern kosher cooking has changed drastically over the past quarter century. With more exotic kosher foods available than ever before and the massively popular cooking shows and print media, it is easy to become a “foodie.” It is exciting to experience new tastes and aromas and to explore different flavors. But for a purist like myself, I have to wonder if having the faux-cheese on my burrito is actually satisfying or just a sad attempt to feel as though we can eat anything we want and still remain within the bounds of Torah law. As a general rule, I try to stay away from such compromises, especially since substitutions often involve artificial ingredients and unhealthy fats. The fresher and more natural the ingredients, the better your food will taste. And though I suppose we all make concessions now and then, when in search of a kosher Philly Cheese Steak sandwich, I opted for a Philly Cheese-less Steak sandwich without hesitation. A different animal, but kosher and delicious all the same.
The key to kosher “substitutions” or just plain doing without, is in knowing how to sufficiently build and intensify flavors in other ways. In this particular case, it is essential to use a tender well-marbled meat (I used shell steak, but rib-eye is also a great choice). Caramelizing sweet onions and peppers with additional spices also boosts flavor. The natural juices are fantastic to savor…even without the cheese whiz.
Kosher Philly Steak Sandwiches
Paper-thin slices can be prepared in advance by Park East Kosher upon request. If slicing your own, simply freeze the meat, thaw halfway and then shave off slices with a sharp carving knife – works like a charm!
Serves 4-6.
3 tbsp. olive oil
1 large Vidalia onion, quartered and thinly sliced
1 green bell pepper, seeded and cut into 2” thin strips
1 sweet red pepper, seeded and cut into 2” thin strips
1 tsp. salt
½ tsp. coriander
½ tsp. cumin
Plenty of freshly ground black pepper, to taste
1 tbsp. canola or vegetable oil
1 ½ lbs. shell steak (or rib eye steak), sliced paper thin and seasoned lightly with kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
6 crusty Italian sub or hoagie rolls
Heat olive oil in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Add the sliced onion and peppers and sauté for about 5-6 minutes, until onion becomes translucent. Add all the spices, stir to blend and continue to sauté for another 6-7 minutes, or until onions become a golden brown color. Transfer mixture to a bowl and add 1 tbsp. canola oil to the hot pan. Place pieces of shaved steak in a single layer on the bottom of the pan. Sear for 1 minute, turn over and sear for another minute. Transfer to a separate bowl and repeat with remaining steak. Slice hoagie rolls almost in half (leaving the two halves connected) and toast lightly, if desired. Fill with pieces of seared steak slices and top with caramelized onion-pepper mixture.
*If making in advance of serving time, the steak sandwich can be reheated – assembled and wrapped in foil in a hot oven.









